|
Technical Notes - Helicopter Electromagnetics
Designing (Digital) HEM for Maximum
Data Quality
Data quality is all that matters. The price
is usually defined or range-limited. What makes a system
successful over its competitors is the ability to deliver
the best quality data within that price range.
INGREDIENTS IN DATA QUALITY
Designed for applications
The system must be designed to serve the geophysical purpose.
One cannot design a system on electronic needs, or on an
expected cost of operation basis, and then try to fit the
geological demands to the system. Electronics-first design
generally benefits the operator by lowering costs, rather
than the user of the data by improving data quality.
-
Frequency range - for a range of
applications, targets, and depths. (380 - 100kHz)
-
Coil Arrangements - the design must
provide for sensitivity to all the targets of interest.
Highly specialised systems can be better for a single
target, but not effective on a project where more
than one target geometry is encountered.
-
"Flyability" - It must
be able to be flown in all environments demanded,
efficiently. For HEM this includes mountains, developed
areas, culturally noisy areas. It must be able to
install and fly with a readily available aircraft.
-
Interpretability - the results
must be definitive of the target, and discriminatory
of the junk. This depends on 1 and 2 above, and on
the processing techniques developed for the system.
Electronic sensitivity, stability
-
High signal to noise. Coil sensitivity
is optimised to each frequency. Fugro has a factor
of 10 range in turns difference between low and high
frequency coils. A single receiver coil cannot be
made as sensitive to each and every frequency measured
over a broad range. Coil separation - need to sample
secondary in presence of primary - move as far as
weight / size / rigidity allows. Pre-amplifiers: Low
noise amplifiers provide higher range of amplification
to allow the designer to optimise the sensor design.
Stable amplifiers reduce drift.
-
Low drift. In a FDEM system, transmitter
(Tx) power is of lower importance - the limit on sensitivity
is the ability to see a weak secondary field in the
presence of the (changing) primary field. Primary
field at the receiver (Rx) changes due to:
-
Changes in primary at Tx (thermal drift of analog
components),
-
changes in Rx-Tx geometry - thermal expansion,
bending, component motion (vibration). This is
accomplished by moving the receiver away from
the transmitter - as far as flyability and weight
limitations will allow. (Longer birds are heavier
due to the length AND the increased thickness
necessary.)
Claims that "Digital doesn't drift" are
misleading. The front end of every EM receiver is
a coil (analog) and a pre-amplifier (analog) and then
an A/D converter. The coils and the pre-amplifiers
are the components in any system most inclined to
drift (when the signals are lowest). The transmitter
coils are analog also. All of these components have
thermal drift. Optimal design will minimise the drift.
-
Calibration. Low drift is no good
if the system wasn't properly calibrated in the first
place. The procedures for calibration must be accurate
and reliable, and the theory behind the calibration
method must be understood to avoid incorrect calibrations.
The reference methods must be more stable than the
system to be calibrated.
Efficient and effective operations
The system must be able to operate more cost effectively
than lower quality / lower cost competitors, to give field
crew the financial latitude to do the job right - to discard
sub-standard data, or not fly during exceptionally noisy
times (spherics or mag storms).
-
Reliability - minimal breakdowns.
Time tested systems.
-
Efficiency - experienced operators,
QC and processing in the field.
-
Training - experienced crews and
established procedures to ensure minimal mistakes.
-
Service - Operation and interpretation
are specialised fields. Clients lacking in this expertise
should be able to rely on contractor to provide all
the support necessary.
Why Go Digital?
-
Reduces drift.
-
Provides for real-time processing: Filtering of
the data (spherics), selective processing and sampling,
Fourier domain processing.
-
Replaces expensive, failure prone hardware with
software processes - easily installed and updated
or adjusted to survey conditions.
-
Allows for addition of computer intelligence to
processing - recognising problems, calibrating (through
noise)
Start with the best possible analog system, and replace
as much of the data collection components as possible.
It must be able to equal or beat the performance of the
analog system on all aspects of data quality - frequency
range, signal, noise, drift, reliability, etc.
Greg Hodges, Chief Geophysicist, 2000
|